Imagine a world where the so-called villain isn't evil at all—she's a fierce champion fighting for the planet and the people. That's the electrifying twist in Wicked: For Good, where Elphaba Thropp, played brilliantly by Cynthia Erivo, steps into her role as an unforgettable symbol of rebellion and hope. But here's where it gets controversial—could our perceptions of heroism be as flawed as a wizard's illusion? Stick around as we dive into this cinematic gem and explore why Elphaba might just be the ecofeminist icon we didn't know we needed.
This sequel wraps up the tale of Elphaba, famously the Wicked Witch of the West, drawing inspiration from L. Frank Baum's classic 1939 story, The Wonderful Wizard of Oz. Born as a novel back in 1995, the Wicked saga blossomed into a beloved Broadway musical in 2003, and now it's a two-part movie series. The second installment, Wicked: For Good, brings Elphaba's journey to a poignant close, cementing her status as one of today's most inspiring environmental warriors in film.
In the finale of the first movie, Elphaba fully embraces her 'wicked' identity after defying the Wizard, portrayed by Jeff Goldblum, and his cunning ally Madame Morrible, played by Michelle Yeoh. Refusing to let them harness her magical abilities, she's banished from the glittering Emerald City and branded a public threat. Her untamed powers escape the regime's grasp, turning her into a spectacle of dread and scorn for the masses. Yet, to viewers, she's a bold trailblazer, defying norms with her unyielding spirit. Her solo independence shines in unforgettable songs like Defying Gravity, which serves as a rallying cry for underdogs everywhere—standing tall for the voiceless and battling unfairness when others won't. In this narrative, Elphaba is the true champion of justice, while the tyrannical Wizard and Madame Morrible emerge as the clear antagonists.
And this is the part most people miss: Elphaba's deep bond with the earth isn't just a plot point; it's the heartbeat of the story. Depicted by her striking green hue and her special connection to animals, she's wild and free-spirited, a stark contrast to the Emerald City's sterile, regimented world. The visuals couldn't be more vivid—the city's flashy, artificial hues, its perfectly trimmed gardens, and its retro-futuristic gadgets clash dramatically with the raw beauty of Elphaba's realm: rugged cliffs dotted with wild blooms and vast, open seas that she soars over on her broom. By opposing the Wizard's harsh policies against animals, Elphaba clashes head-on with a system that muzzles the weakest. This positions her as a powerful ecofeminist resistor.
For those new to the term, ecofeminism—coined in 1974 by French thinker Françoise d'Eaubonne in her groundbreaking book Feminism or Death—highlights how the mistreatment of women and the environment stem from identical power imbalances and dominance. Think of it like this: just as patriarchal structures might suppress women's voices, industrial systems might exploit natural resources without regard for the planet's health. Marginalized and dreaded for her potent magic, Elphaba personifies this fight against the dual injustices faced by women and nature. By shielding Oz's creatures and rebelling against control, she becomes a beacon for ecofeminist defiance.
This perspective gains even more depth through the insights of American scholar Carolyn Merchant, whose work emphasizes how contemporary power relies on seeing nature as a machine to be manipulated. The Wizard's efforts to quiet and dominate animals exemplify this cold, mechanical view, reducing living creatures to mere cogs in his orderly kingdom. Elphaba, on the other hand, adopts a nurturing, interconnected view of the world, grounded in reverence rather than conquest. By pitting her against the Wizard, Wicked: For Good portrays her as a revolutionary force, seizing back autonomy for herself and the ecosystems she protects.
The movie also underscores how bonds between women can ignite change. Ecofeminism stresses the importance of relationships and nurturing care—think of it as building strength through empathy and support rather than rivalry. Elphaba's friendship with the 'good witch' Glinda, brought to life by Ariana Grande, mirrors this perfectly. Sure, there's a brief romantic entanglement that complicates things, but the film wisely avoids turning them into foes. Instead, it celebrates their growing alliance as a wellspring of resilience and ethical insight. Their supportive dynamic stands in sharp opposition to the Wizard's hunger for supremacy.
By the time the credits roll on Wicked: For Good, Elphaba transcends her label as Oz's misunderstood enchantress. She's evolved into an eco-heroine who prompts us to rethink fear-mongering and how authority shapes our inherited myths. Her power stems from empathy and the bravery to live authentically. Far from villainous, she's a timeless mentor, embodying the revolutionary might of compassion and solidarity.
Looking for something good? Cut through the noise with a carefully curated selection of the latest releases, live events and exhibitions, straight to your inbox every fortnight, on Fridays. Sign up here.
This article features references to books that have been included for editorial reasons, and may contain links to bookshop.org – if you click on one of the links and go on to buy something, The Conversation UK may earn a commission.
What do you think—does recasting villains as heroes like Elphaba challenge our views on power and nature in ways we should embrace, or does it risk oversimplifying real-world struggles? Do you see ecofeminism as a vital lens for modern stories, or is there a controversial edge here that makes you question its application? Share your thoughts in the comments—agreements, disagreements, or fresh takes are all welcome!
